Torque - Scan-and-Solve for Rhino2024-03-29T06:08:05Zhttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/forum/topics/torque-1?commentId=6083097%3AComment%3A2243&feed=yes&xn_auth=noHi Simon, Michael
Torque wou…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-12-01:6083097:Comment:23722010-12-01T09:08:42.000ZIan Boydhttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/IanBoyd
Hi Simon, Michael<br />
<br />
Torque would be a very good option to have. I also had to do a little workaround on a recent project. Not as critical as turbine shafts, but nevertheless a substantial investment in tooling.<br />
<br />
Also, I used simple scalar forces. Haven't had a chance to play with vector forces yet. Should be possible to set that up to simulate a tangential load which may be fine for non-critical applications.<br />
<br />
Incidentally, we are expecting delivery of an acrylic 3D print this afternoon. Sns was…
Hi Simon, Michael<br />
<br />
Torque would be a very good option to have. I also had to do a little workaround on a recent project. Not as critical as turbine shafts, but nevertheless a substantial investment in tooling.<br />
<br />
Also, I used simple scalar forces. Haven't had a chance to play with vector forces yet. Should be possible to set that up to simulate a tangential load which may be fine for non-critical applications.<br />
<br />
Incidentally, we are expecting delivery of an acrylic 3D print this afternoon. Sns was used to find a load with acrylic that gives similar values to the polypropylene we plan to use... admittedly a little "rough & ready" but will allow us to conduct a certain amount of validation with the acrylic model.<br />
<br />
Ian<br />
<br />
PS (loving SnS - keep up the good work) Here´s a sample of that, what…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-11-20:6083097:Comment:22512010-11-20T21:50:08.000ZSimon Klopphttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/SimonKlopp
Here´s a sample of that, what I mean! Should work...
Here´s a sample of that, what I mean! Should work... Hello Micheal!
Thank for thi…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-11-20:6083097:Comment:22462010-11-20T21:00:05.000ZSimon Klopphttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/SimonKlopp
Hello Micheal!<br></br>
<br></br>
Thank for this information! At the moment, I attach some kind of a crank on the testing shaft, to produce a kind of torque on it. I think this is not really a torque force because SnS has no information about the rotation axis and calcualtes more as a kind of movement. This should IMHO the only possible way to test it, or what do you (as you know your algorithm) think about? <br></br>
<br></br>
I think an intuitive way for everyone is to choose out a surface or crosssection of…
Hello Micheal!<br/>
<br/>
Thank for this information! At the moment, I attach some kind of a crank on the testing shaft, to produce a kind of torque on it. I think this is not really a torque force because SnS has no information about the rotation axis and calcualtes more as a kind of movement. This should IMHO the only possible way to test it, or what do you (as you know your algorithm) think about? <br/>
<br/>
I think an intuitive way for everyone is to choose out a surface or crosssection of a solid, determine the "rotoation" direction and the ammount of torque (in Nm).<br/>
<br/>
Same should be to calculate the centrifugal force by choosing axis direction, material and speed.<br/>
<br/>
Maybe you can find a way to insert the torque and cetrifugal force operations on an further step of development.<br/>
<br/>
Best Regards<br/>
<br/>
Simon Simon,
Your English reads fin…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-11-20:6083097:Comment:22432010-11-20T18:06:58.000ZMichael Freytaghttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/MichaelFreytag
Simon,<br />
Your English reads fine to me.<br />
<br />
In its present incarnation, Scan&Solve does not have a simple way to enter torque loads except to divide the surface of the geometry into smaller portions as you've done.<br />
<br />
We will have to ponder for a bit on how to add torque capability in a manner that is intuitive to the majority of users.<br />
<br />
Thanks,<br />
Michael
Simon,<br />
Your English reads fine to me.<br />
<br />
In its present incarnation, Scan&Solve does not have a simple way to enter torque loads except to divide the surface of the geometry into smaller portions as you've done.<br />
<br />
We will have to ponder for a bit on how to add torque capability in a manner that is intuitive to the majority of users.<br />
<br />
Thanks,<br />
Michael