at last!! - Scan-and-Solve for Rhino2024-03-28T08:33:30Zhttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/forum/topics/at-last?commentId=6083097%3AComment%3A2489&feed=yes&xn_auth=noFinally,i reviewed this discu…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-12-07:6083097:Comment:24892010-12-07T05:40:02.000ZRichard.Lhttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/RichardL
Finally,i reviewed this discussion.<br/>
<br/>
I agree with you very much,Michael.<br/>
As to this kind of plus-in,I'd like to choose script such as shells ,tcl/TK ...etc ,and the Rhino script, Even text.<br/>
<br/>
Simple<br/>
Flexible<br/>
Applicable<br/>
Neutral<br/>
Efficient<br/>
Expansibility<br/>
<br/>
are my words with script-choose .Especially driving parameters for optimization.<br />
<br />
I'm not familiar with the operation of GH either,:(
Finally,i reviewed this discussion.<br/>
<br/>
I agree with you very much,Michael.<br/>
As to this kind of plus-in,I'd like to choose script such as shells ,tcl/TK ...etc ,and the Rhino script, Even text.<br/>
<br/>
Simple<br/>
Flexible<br/>
Applicable<br/>
Neutral<br/>
Efficient<br/>
Expansibility<br/>
<br/>
are my words with script-choose .Especially driving parameters for optimization.<br />
<br />
I'm not familiar with the operation of GH either,:( This sounds exiting. In the m…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-08-23:6083097:Comment:6802010-08-23T06:44:54.000ZArmido Cremaschihttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/ArmidoCremaschi
This sounds exiting. In the meanwhile, since iteration with different shapes is always necessary, would it be possible to avoid applying Material, Restraints, Loads every time? Just hitting GO! after selecting the new solid would load the last options.<br />
A big time-saver.<br />
Ciao<br />
Armido
This sounds exiting. In the meanwhile, since iteration with different shapes is always necessary, would it be possible to avoid applying Material, Restraints, Loads every time? Just hitting GO! after selecting the new solid would load the last options.<br />
A big time-saver.<br />
Ciao<br />
Armido I suppose that as long as SnS…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-08-21:6083097:Comment:6532010-08-21T11:27:41.000ZCristian Luca Atzorihttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/CristianLucaAtzori
I suppose that as long as SnS can ouput it's results in form of numeric values directly to a TXT file we can do this.<br />
<br />
GH can read data from external files.<br />
<br />
Even with a single selectable value in the output (say, Total deflection or Maximum Stress).<br />
<br />
You could make them interact directly in the future, but an output in form of a TXT file can be usefull for many reasons.<br />
<br />
The only problem I can think of, in that case, is: how can GH know that the solution is ready (and the TXT)?<br />
But we must…
I suppose that as long as SnS can ouput it's results in form of numeric values directly to a TXT file we can do this.<br />
<br />
GH can read data from external files.<br />
<br />
Even with a single selectable value in the output (say, Total deflection or Maximum Stress).<br />
<br />
You could make them interact directly in the future, but an output in form of a TXT file can be usefull for many reasons.<br />
<br />
The only problem I can think of, in that case, is: how can GH know that the solution is ready (and the TXT)?<br />
But we must solve it in the Gh domain...maybe with a timed recursive check. (?) I'm not familiar with the ope…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-08-20:6083097:Comment:6392010-08-20T21:56:31.000ZMichael Freytaghttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/MichaelFreytag
I'm not familiar with the operation of GH. Would the ability to control Scan&Solve via Rhino script meet this need, or do you think we'd need something different?
I'm not familiar with the operation of GH. Would the ability to control Scan&Solve via Rhino script meet this need, or do you think we'd need something different? Think of a reiteration, from…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-08-20:6083097:Comment:6282010-08-20T18:52:49.000ZCristian Luca Atzorihttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/CristianLucaAtzori
Think of a reiteration, from GH to SnS, when you can correlate the thickness of the surface (a slider in GH) with a specified value of maximum stress in MPa, and automatically increase the thickness until the stress goes below that value.<br />
<br />
It would be FANTASTIC.<br />
<br />
Or the same, but joining the total deflection (or X, Y, Z) with another valute in GH, like for example the lenght of a beam, of the height of the core of an H steel profile...<br />
<br />
Let's put this in the wishlist :)
Think of a reiteration, from GH to SnS, when you can correlate the thickness of the surface (a slider in GH) with a specified value of maximum stress in MPa, and automatically increase the thickness until the stress goes below that value.<br />
<br />
It would be FANTASTIC.<br />
<br />
Or the same, but joining the total deflection (or X, Y, Z) with another valute in GH, like for example the lenght of a beam, of the height of the core of an H steel profile...<br />
<br />
Let's put this in the wishlist :) I assume that this descriptio…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-08-20:6083097:Comment:6232010-08-20T17:46:58.000ZVadim Shapirohttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/VadimShapiro
I assume that this description goes with this movie you posted?<br />
<a href="http://www.scan-and-solve.com/video/grasshopper-scan-and-solve" target="_blank">http://www.scan-and-solve.com/video/grasshopper-scan-and-solve</a><br />
<br />
Very cool! ... this question probably belongs to grasshopper board, but looking at your work, it would be nice to integrate Scan and Solve with Grasshopper more tightly, wouldn't it? How would you improve it?
I assume that this description goes with this movie you posted?<br />
<a href="http://www.scan-and-solve.com/video/grasshopper-scan-and-solve" target="_blank">http://www.scan-and-solve.com/video/grasshopper-scan-and-solve</a><br />
<br />
Very cool! ... this question probably belongs to grasshopper board, but looking at your work, it would be nice to integrate Scan and Solve with Grasshopper more tightly, wouldn't it? How would you improve it? Can we see more details? Plea…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-08-17:6083097:Comment:5092010-08-17T17:47:35.000ZVadim Shapirohttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/VadimShapiro
Can we see more details? Please? Of course, we have been thinking "shape & topology optimization" -- but you are already half way there!
Can we see more details? Please? Of course, we have been thinking "shape & topology optimization" -- but you are already half way there! Well i did not reaply the loa…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-08-17:6083097:Comment:5082010-08-17T15:31:43.000Zmario vergarahttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/mariovergara
Well i did not reaply the loads, that was the point.<br />
In gh i used a voronoi subdv.<br />
So the parameter i changed was the amount of offset of the Voronoi cell.<br />
That produced thicker or thinner beams.<br />
Then i was was able to see when the structure would collapse.<br />
The model presents a bridge that is connecting two buildings, so both ends are constrainted to those existing structures.<br />
best
Well i did not reaply the loads, that was the point.<br />
In gh i used a voronoi subdv.<br />
So the parameter i changed was the amount of offset of the Voronoi cell.<br />
That produced thicker or thinner beams.<br />
Then i was was able to see when the structure would collapse.<br />
The model presents a bridge that is connecting two buildings, so both ends are constrainted to those existing structures.<br />
best So, you could change the GH m…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-08-17:6083097:Comment:5072010-08-17T15:19:18.000ZScott Davidsonhttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/ScottDavidson
So, you could change the GH model, then bake and test. Very fun. I guess you would also need to re-apply loads.<br />
<br />
What does the model represent? What elements can you changing in GH that effectted the structure for SNS?
So, you could change the GH model, then bake and test. Very fun. I guess you would also need to re-apply loads.<br />
<br />
What does the model represent? What elements can you changing in GH that effectted the structure for SNS? Scott.
No, they are nort work…tag:www.scan-and-solve.com,2010-08-17:6083097:Comment:4962010-08-17T01:55:16.000Zmario vergarahttp://www.scan-and-solve.com/profile/mariovergara
Scott.<br />
No, they are nort working together, the model was made with gh, but i had to bake it in order to use sns.
Scott.<br />
No, they are nort working together, the model was made with gh, but i had to bake it in order to use sns.